In this article...

Watch Our Video
Kevin O'Flaherty

In Indiana, a breach of contract is recognized as one party’s failure to meet their responsibilities under a legally-binding agreement. This means they didn't follow through with their part of the deal. If a breach happens, there are different legal outcomes for the people involved, and these depend on what exactly went wrong. Individuals who have suffered from non-compliance with agreements have multiple legal avenues available for seeking redress, including: monetary reparation, enforcement through specific performance, annulment, and restitution.

Key Takeaways

  • In Indiana, breaching a contract allows the non-breaching party to seek remedies or damages; the breaching party can claim defenses like impossibility.
  • To allege a breach, one must prove a valid contract, their duty fulfillment, and damages caused by the breach; defendants can counter with their defenses.
  • Remedies include compensatory, consequential, and restitutionary damages, plus equitable remedies like specific performance, limited by a statute of limitations.

What Constitutes a Broken Promise?

At its core, a contract represents an agreement or pledge. When that pledged word is not honored, it results in what’s known as a breach of contract. In the state of Indiana, this takes place when any party involved does not fulfill their responsibilities agreed upon within the terms of the contract. These duties can encompass anything from providing goods to adhering to specified service deadlines.

Often times, failure or refusal by a party to perform according to contractual obligations without a lawful excuse results in such breaches and consequent accountability for reparations due to damages incurred. Contentions may emerge over interpretations related to various aspects like work scope or pricing within contracts – these differences can prompt questions about whether there has been a violation of contractual commitments. The nature and details surrounding breaches are as diverse as the myriad types of contracts that exist.

The Legal Anatomy of a Contract

A contract is much more than mere paper. It’s a legally binding entity with its own structure. For a contract to be recognized as valid, several critical elements must be present.

  • A clear and precise offer
  • Unconditional acceptance by the offeree
  • Consideration that has tangible value, such as money, property or services
  • Parties who are legally able to engage in contractual agreements.

For an offer to set forth the terms of a contract effectively, it needs to be specific, unequivocal and detailed enough so there’s no uncertainty regarding the intent to form an agreement. When this offer receives absolute consent from whom it was made without any changes proposed—the moment we have what’s termed ‘acceptance’. Furthermore, ‘consideration’ is essentially about the transfer of something valuable between those entering into the contractual obligation, whether this might involve finances, assets or some kind of work performed.

In order for one party’s allegation against another concerning breach of contract to hold weight in legal proceedings one should confirm that all these core aspects were met ensuring legality can enforce said agreement.

Proving Your Case: Evidence and Arguments

When engaged in a contract dispute, the strength of your evidence and the persuasiveness of your argument are essential tools. Essential forms of evidence to compile include:

  • Documents related to the contract
  • Records of correspondence
  • Drafts from negotiations
  • Financial documentation
  • Records demonstrating fulfillment or performance issues
  • Billing documents

Information regarding other written contracts can be obtained through governmental databases and third-party online platforms which could shed light on parties’ adherence or non-compliance with contractual commitments.

During litigation, discovery is an indispensable phase that allows for gathering critical records required to support the party initiating legal action. The collected proof must effectively show several points.

That there was a legally binding agreement in place.

That all obligations under the contract were met by who brought the lawsuit.

That there was a failure on behalf of those being sued to uphold their end.

And that this breach led directly to losses experienced by plaintiff.

Responding to Allegations: Counterclaims and Affirmative Defenses

In responding to allegations, it is crucial not only to defend oneself, but also to launch counterattacks through counterclaims and affirmative defenses. Within Indiana, these can include:

  • assertions that fulfilling the contract was impossible or excessively burdensome
  • the contention that the central purpose of a contract has been thwarted
  • various specific provisions within a contract which might act as legitimate grounds for defense
  • lapse due to reaching the time limit imposed by statute of limitations.

Defendants have options like putting forward their own claims against other parties involved, including cross and third-party claims.

Damages and Remedies for Breach of Contract

Illustration of scales of justice symbolizing legal remedies

When a breach of contract occurs, it often results in various forms of loss and damage. In response to this, Indiana law acknowledges several kinds of damages that can be claimed in cases involving a breach of contract. These are:

  • Compensatory damages aimed at reimbursing actual losses incurred
  • Consequential damages for losses not directly stemming from the breach itself
  • Restitutionary damages designed to prevent one party from being unjustly enriched at the other’s expense.

To financial reparations, equitable remedies exist as well. The act of rescission can dissolve a contractual agreement and revert involved parties back to their pre-contractual state. Conversely, an injunction might mandate particular actions or inhibit specific behaviors. These measures come into play when mere monetary compensation is inadequate. Nevertheless, the responsibility does not lie solely with the aggrieved party—India enforces an obligation upon them to diminish any harm by reasonably reducing Loss.

Although there is no fixed upper limit on compensatory damages within Indiana law, stipulations govern liquidated damages: such predetermined sums must reflect a realistic prediction concerning prospective losses attributable to breaches in contracts. Thus individuals who have suffered from non-compliance with agreements have multiple legal avenues available for seeking redress, including:

  • monetary reparation
  • enforcement through specific performance
  • annulment
  • restitution

The choice among these options should be considered carefully regarding each unique situation’s attributes along with potential consequences under law and effects pertaining specifically to personal property rights related issues.

Statute of Limitations for Filing a Lawsuit

In terms of Indiana law:

  • A ten-year statute of limitations applies to breaches involving written contracts.
  • Breaches related to oral agreements or unwritten contracts fall under a six-year period — this is also referred to as the “six year statute.”
  • The same six-year limit governs actions on written contracts designed for money payments such as promissory notes and bills of exchange.

Is breach of contract illegal?

No.  Breach of contract is a civil action, like a lawsuit for personal injuries would be.  The breach, in and of itself, is not illegal, although the act amounting to the breach might independently be actionable as a violation of some criminal law.  

Frequently Asked Questions

Who has the burden of proof in a breach of contract case?

The party filing the Complaint for breach of contract has the burden of proving his case by a preponderance of the evidence.  If the responding party files a counterclaim or affirmative defense(s), the respondent would have the burden of proving the allegations in the counterclaim or affirmative defense(s).  

How do you prove breach of contract?

The plaintiff must prove that a valid contract was entered into by the parties, what the terms of the contract were, that plaintiff performed all obligations plaintiff had under the contract, but that the responding party failed or refused to perform respondent’s obligations under the contract.  Plaintiff must then prove that the damages sought were proximately caused by respondent’s breach.  

How much can you sue for breach of contract in Indiana?

There is no limit on the amount that you can sue for in breach of contract in the state of Indiana.

Is it worth suing for breach of contract in Indiana?

Only the individual contemplating a lawsuit can weigh whether they can afford what it might take to prove their case.  This is why a person contemplating any litigation should contact an experienced litigator to discuss whether extensive discovery, depositions, experienced witnesses, pretrial motions, and the like might be necessary and what the costs to you might be.

What is the statute of limitations on breach of contract in Indiana?

The statute of limitations for breach of oral or written professional services contracts is two (2) years.  The statute of limitations for breach of all other types of oral contracts is six (6) years.  The statute of limitations for breach of all other written contracts is ten (10) years.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this blog is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject matter. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Each individual's legal needs are unique, and these materials may not be applicable to your legal situation. Always seek the advice of a competent attorney with any questions you may have regarding a legal issue. Do not disregard professional legal advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this blog.

FREE Business, Corporate & Contract LawE-Book

Get my FREE E-Book

Similar Articles

Learn about Law