In this article...

Watch Our Video
Kevin O'Flaherty

You were in a car accident a while ago that didn't seem to do any harm to the other car or driver, but now the other driver has sued you. You don't deny that you were involved in the crash, but you don't think the lawsuit's allegations are true. Although you can battle the case in court, it will take a significant amount of time and resources. Wondering how to get a small claims case dismissed in Wisconsin? This guide cuts through the complexity to provide clear, actionable steps. You’ll learn the legitimate grounds for dismissal, understand how to file the right paperwork and get precise insights to navigate Wisconsin’s small claims court effectively. Prepare to walk through each stage of the dismissal process with confidence; we’ve got the practical advice you need for a clear path forward.

The Basics of a Motion to Dismiss  

A dismissal in small claims court essentially means that the case is terminated before it’s completed, thereby absolving the plaintiff’s claim to any requested money. Sounds simple, right? But what triggers a dismissal? It can be due to a variety of factors, primarily if the plaintiff fails to abide by court rules or orders.

Let’s explore the reasons for dismissal further, as well as the difference between a motion to dismiss and a request for dismissal.

Justifications for a Motion to Dismiss  

A motion to dismiss may be brought for many reasons, many of which are based on legal flaws. The following are some of the most important reasons for filing a motion to dismiss:  

Insufficient Process Service: The complaint and summons were not adequately served.  

The Statute of Limitations has Run Out: Wisconsin has its own "statutes of limitations," or time limits for filing such litigation.  

Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction: A court must have "subject matter jurisdiction," or the power to hear a certain form of case, in order to rule on it.  

Lack of Personal Jurisdiction: In order to make a decision involving a defendant, a judge must have "personal jurisdiction" over the defendant. When a party is a citizen or has "reasonable minimum connections" with the jurisdiction where the case was brought, the court has personal jurisdiction over him or her.  

Improper Venue: Even if a court has personal authority over the parties, it could be the wrong "venue," which refers to the court's physical location.

Failure to State a Claim for Which Relief May Be Granted: When filing a lawsuit, a plaintiff must meet a number of conditions, including having a legitimate cause of action. If the plaintiff's complaint fails to adequately allege all of the elements of a claim or fails to allege a measurable injury, the court can grant a motion to dismiss.  

Motion to Dismiss vs. Request for Dismissal

Having established the grounds for dismissal, we now need to understand who can file for it. This leads us to distinguish between a motion to dismiss and a request for dismissal. A motion to dismiss is typically the defendant’s initial response to the complaint, arguing that the complaint lacks the necessary elements of a legal claim. On the other hand, a request for dismissal is usually filed by the plaintiff as a voluntary action to terminate their case.

What is the Process for Filing a Motion to Dismiss?  

The first step in your journey is to fill out a Request for Dismissal form and a Notice of Entry of Dismissal and Proof of Service if required. Think of this as packing your bags. The Request for Dismissal form is like your passport, giving you the authority to initiate the dismissal process.

Once you’ve filled out the necessary forms, it’s time to make copies. Just as you would take a picture of your passport before traveling, make two copies of your dismissal forms. These forms, such as SC-5300VA “Stipulation for Dismissal Eviction (Small Claims)” or SC-5310VA “Stipulation for Dismissal Non-Eviction (Small Claims)”, record the terms of your agreement to dismiss the case. When filled out correctly and thoroughly, these documents form the backbone of your dismissal request.

Filing the Motion or Request

Once your forms are filled and copied, the next step is to file the motion or request with the court clerk. This step is akin to checking in before a flight. Ensure that all your forms are correctly filled out and then submit them to the court clerk at the courthouse where your small claims case was filed. Once the clerk receives your forms, your case is officially on its way to being dismissed.

Serving the Other Party

Hold on, we’re not done yet! Serving the other party is a crucial step in the dismissal process. Just as you would notify your bank when you’re traveling abroad, you must inform the other party of the dismissal. This notification is typically done through the Notice of Entry of Dismissal and Proof of Service, which is served along with a copy of the filed Request for Dismissal.

But who needs to be served, and how can it be done? Let’s explore this.

Who Must Be Served

So, who exactly needs to be served when seeking a dismissal? In most cases, it’s the other party involved in the small claims case. Think of it as sending a postcard from your travels - it’s crucial to address it to the right person.

The party who files the dismissal must serve the other party, ensuring they are aware of the dismissal process and can act accordingly.

Methods of Service

Now that we’ve established who needs to be served, let’s explore how to do it. From personal delivery by the Sheriff or a private process server to regular or certified mail, the methods of service are varied. It’s like choosing your mode of travel - each method serves a unique purpose and is suited to different circumstances.

Regardless of the method chosen, the goal remains the same: to ensure the other party is informed about the dismissal.

Making a decision on a Motion to Dismiss  

When considering a motion to dismiss, courts believe that the facts and claims in the case are true and will interpret them in the plaintiff's favor. As a result, prevailing on a motion to dismiss is usually difficult. The case can be dismissed "without prejudice" or "with prejudice" if it is granted. The case can be re-filed at a later date if it is dismissed without discrimination. A case that is dismissed with prejudice, on the other hand, is closed and cannot be re-filed.  

The court may also dismiss a case "sua sponte," meaning without any prompting from either side. Where there are reasons for dismissing a lawsuit, the court has this choice. Even if no party objects to the location in which the case was brought, the court may nevertheless dismiss the case due to inappropriate venue.  

Is it Necessary to File a Motion to Dismiss?

Plaintiffs and defendants must also obey a set of procedural guidelines when filing a lawsuit. Failure to do so could result in a negative outcome in your case.  If you're considering filing a lawsuit or have already been served with one, the safest course of action is to speak with a local litigation attorney about the options moving forward.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you appeal a small claims court decision in Wisconsin?

Yes, if you are dissatisfied with a small claims court decision in Wisconsin, you may appeal it to the Wisconsin Court of Appeals.

How do I dismiss a court case in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin, a defendant can file a motion to dismiss a court case based on legal grounds such as lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Additionally, a plaintiff can dismiss the case by serving and filing a notice of dismissal before the adverse party serves a responsive pleading or motion.

What is the burden of proof in small claims court in Wisconsin?

In small claims court in Wisconsin, each party must prove their claim "by the greater weight of credible evidence," with the plaintiff presenting evidence first, followed by the defendant, and both parties testifying truthfully.

What is the threshold for small claims court in Wisconsin?

In Wisconsin, the threshold for small claims court is $10,000 or less, with some exceptions for certain types of claims.

What is the purpose of a motion to dismiss?

The purpose of a motion to dismiss is to ask the judge to dismiss the plaintiff's case, which is outlined in the complaint filed at the start of a civil lawsuit.

Request a consultation with an attorney. Call our office at (630) 324-6666 or schedule a consultation with one of our experienced lawyers today. You can also fill out our confidential contact form and we will get back to you shortly.

Disclaimer: The information provided on this blog is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject matter. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Each individual's legal needs are unique, and these materials may not be applicable to your legal situation. Always seek the advice of a competent attorney with any questions you may have regarding a legal issue. Do not disregard professional legal advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this blog.

FREE Litigation & Dispute ResolutionE-Book

Get my FREE E-Book

Similar Articles

Learn about Law