What is “Substitute Decision-Making?”

Basics of Substitute Decision-Making | What Are the Options for Substitute Decision-Making in Illinois?

Updated on:
October 31, 2018

In this article, we will discuss the basic options for substitute decision-making in Illinois, including guardianship, powers of attorney, and surrogates.  We will answer “What is a Guardianship in Illinois?” “What is Power of Attorney in Illinois?” and “What are Surrogates in Illinois?”

What is “Substitute Decision-Making?”

Substitute decision-making is the process of legally declaring someone as responsible for another person.   Usually, if someone is over the age of 18, the state of Illinois recognizes them as an adult who is responsible for their own legal and financial decision making.  However, if a person is unable to make decisions for themselves, it is possible to legally declare someone as a decision maker for the adult.  This is typically done when someone is no longer of sound enough mind to make decisions in their own best interest, such as an elderly citizen or a developmentally-disabled adult.  There are several types and levels of power within substitute decision-making in Illinois.  These options have a variety of powers and can be significant changes to the lives of both the decision maker and the person they are making decisions for, so if you are looking for a decision maker for yourself or a loved one, it is important to consider the options available for you.  

What is a Guardianship in Illinois?

An adult guardian is a person or agency appointed by the court to make decisions for an adult who is unable to make decisions for themselves. Guardians must be appointed by the court as the person responsible for someone’s decision making who is otherwise unable to make decisions for themselves.  If a guardian is appointed, they will be responsible for regularly reporting to the court on expenses. The court also has the ability to change the guardian or their duties if they believe they are not acting within the best interest of the person they are assigned to.  Think of the guardian as manager who must report to their boss on their job.  If the boss (the court) believes that the manager (the guardian) is not working well with their employee (the person they are assigned to), they can be removed or have their powers adjusted.  Guardianship could be temporary, but are most often considered permanent.

For more on Guardianship, see our article and video “What is a Court Appointed Guardian?”

What is a Power of Attorney in Illinois?

A Power of Attorney is a signed legal document which assigns a person to make your decisions for you if you reach a point where you are unable to make decisions for yourself.  Unlike guardianship, a Power of Attorney is not regulated and checked by the courts and is instead assigned directly by the person who the Power of Attorney will be making decisions for.  The role and power that a person with Power of Attorney has is malleable.  For example, you can assign a General Power of Attorney that has power of every decision such as financial and business decisions, much like a Guardian.  However, you can also assign Power of Attorney to a special or specific type of decision. For example, you can have a Power of Attorney who is only allowed to make decisions for your health care or one who is only allowed to make decisions for your business.  As a power of attorney is not in check by the courts, it is important to be sure that whomever you assign as Power of Attorney is someone you trust to make the best decisions in the situations they are given power over.  

For more on Power of Attorney, see out article and video “Power of Attorney Explained.”

What are Surrogates in Illinois Law?

A surrogate decision maker is someone who can make emergency health care decisions for someone who is unable to decide for themselves.  Often, this falls on the next of kin who will have to make the decision on behalf of their loved one.  Which family member is next of kin can vary by state.  Here in Illinois, the first level of Next of Kin is the spouse and/or the child of the person.  The surrogate for emergency health care decisions can also be a Power of Attorney who is given the right to make health care decisions.  Sometimes, a person may choose to give this power to a doctor who works regularly with them and is trusted to not only make decisions that reflect their desires, but also have an understanding of what decisions will mean.  In a surrogate situation, the decision-maker must be able to make the decision that they believe the incapacitated person would have made for themselves regardless of the surrogate’s personal views or their own desires.   This can be a difficult situation to be in, so, if you are assigning someone specific to make this decision, make sure they are someone who knows you well and can also make decisions that reflect your own desires, even in high pressure situations.  

Presented By O'Flaherty Law

O'Flaherty Law is happy to meet with you by phone or at our offices in Downers Grove, Elmhurst, Naperville, St. Charles, Lake in the Hills and Tinley Park, Illinois.

What to Expect From a Consultation

The purpose of a free consultation is to determine whether our firm is a good fit for your legal needs. Although we often discuss expected results and costs, our attorneys do not give legal advice unless and until you choose to retain us. Although most consultations are complimentary, some may carry a charge depending on the type of matter and meeting location.

Leave a Comment With Your Questions

Read more about


Basics of Substitute Decision-Making | What Are the Options for Substitute Decision-Making in Illinois?
Disclaimer: Our articles and comment responses do not constitute legal advice and are not intended to create an attorney-client relationship.

Please contact us to schedule a free consultation for legal advice specific to your situation.

What is a Power of Attorney in Illinois?What are Surrogates in Illinois Law?What is Surrogate Decision Making in Illinois?What is the difference between Power of Attorney and Guardianship in Illinois?Who is the next of kin in Illinois?who can make decisions for someone who lacks capacity in Illinois?

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required

Here are some articles that may interest you