no need to leave your home to receive legal consultations and services - Call or click to learn more about phone and videoconferencing with our attorneys

Motions For Summary Judgment Explained | Illinois Litigation

Article written by Illinois & Iowa Attorney Kevin O'Flaherty
Updated on
October 28, 2019

In civil litigation, the purpose of a trial is for either a jury or the judge to decide facts that are in dispute.  If the plaintiff's story differs from that of the defendant, the trier of fact (the judge or jury) must decide which story is more likely to be true, and rule in that party's favor.  

‍However, sometimes a trial is not necessary.  Parties file motions for summary judgment, requesting judgment in their favor without a trial, when either there is no dispute as to the material facts, or the other side cannot prove their claims or defenses. 

‍Courts will grant a motion for summary judgment and enter judgment in favor of the party filing the motion when the party filing the motion can show that: (1) there is no dispute as to the material facts of the case; and (2) based on the undisputed facts, the party filing the motion is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. 

‍A motion for summary judgment will be filed along with a brief to the court, called a Memorandum in Support of the Motion for Summary Judgment.  In the Memorandum, the party filing the motion will lay out the legal elements of his or her claim or defense and make the argument that there is enough undisputed or indisputable evidence to support that claim or defense.  The party filing the motion will attach affidavits, deposition testimony, and other evidence as exhibits to the Memorandum.  The filer need not show that the parties agree on every fact in the case.  Rather, the filing party need only show that they can prove the limited set of facts necessary to their claim or defense, and that the other side cannot disprove these facts or raise other facts to defeat them.  It is not enough to show that the story of the party filing the motion is likely to be true than that of the other side.  Rather they must show that there are no reasonably disputable facts that are essential to their claim, so that there would be nothing for the jury or judge to decide at trial.

‍After the motion and memorandum have been filed, the responding party will file a brief called a Response, making either a legal or factual argument that: (1) there is a genuine dispute as to the facts making up the other party's claims or defenses; (2) even if there is no dispute as to the other party's case in chief, there are other facts or legal claims which can overcome it; or (3) even if there is no dispute as to the facts cited by the other party, the statutory law or case law would not entitle the other party to win at trial.  

‍After the Response brief has been filed, the party that filed the motion will file a Reply brief, responding to the arguments raised in the Response brief.  

‍Once the Memorandum in Support of the Motion, the Response brief, and the Reply brief have been submitted to the court, the parties' attorneys will conduct an oral argument at a hearing before the court.  Many judges will have read the briefs in detail, performed their own independent research, and be prepared with questions for each side, or issues for the attorneys to address in oral argument.   Often, however, judges will have only skimmed the briefs prior to oral argument, and will rely on the attorneys to lay out the bases for their motion or defense in full, before reading the briefs in more detail after the hearing for proof and clarification.  

‍Whether to file a Motion For Summary Judgment is a difficult decision that should ultimately be left up to the client, with the advice of their attorney.  If you are able to win on a motion for summary judgment, you may save a significant amount of money that it would cost to prepare the case for trial and try the case.  However, motions for summary judgment can require a significant amount of attorney time, and there is always a risk that you will not be successful.  

‍If I feel that my clients have a significant chance to win the motion, I will often advise them in favor of filing the Motion for Summary Judgment, notwithstanding the risk that they may lose at hearing, because even unsuccessful motions are not a waste of attorney time.  Much of the work that will ultimately go into preparing for trial, including formulating legal arguments and compiling evidence, will be accomplished in preparing the Motion For Summary Judgment, and will not have to be redone if the motion is unsuccessful and the case goes to trial.  Ultimately, the decision on whether a Motion For Summary Judgment is a good strategy must be deliberated in light of the facts of each particular case.  ​

Additional Financial Considerations
from Financial Experts

From Financial Experts

For many years, financial institutions have been creating a disservice to clients and the industry as a whole for years.
View More Professional Considerations

Presented By O'Flaherty Law

what is a motion for summary judgment?

Need Legal Help? 

Schedule a

What to Expect From a Consultation

The purpose of a free consultation is to determine whether our firm is a good fit for your legal needs. Although we often discuss expected results and costs, our attorneys do not give legal advice unless and until you choose to retain us. Although most consultations are complimentary, some may carry a charge depending on the type of matter and meeting location.

Leave a Comment With Your Questions

Read more about

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

We offer free, paid & Online CONSULTATION in:

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

Schedule a consultation with our Illinois & Iowa Attorneys

We offer free, paid & online consultation in nearly every area of law throughout Illinois and Iowa. We have a range of options to assist you with your legal needs.

What happens at a legal consultation?
Meet with an attorney for a free consultation to discuss what type of matter you need to discuss with an attorney.
Over the Phone Legal Consultations
Similar to In-person consultations, you discuss your legal needs with our attorneys to discuss your matter.
An online consultation is like an in-person and an over the phone online Consultation. You meet face to face with our attorneys through our online portal.
Paid Legal Consultations
While a free consultation allows us to discuss what we can do in general terms for your legal matter, a paid consultation allows us to answer direct questions.

More Illinois Civil Defense Law Episodes

contact us

Monday to Friday
9am - 5pm

Contact Us
Disclaimer: Our articles and comment responses do not constitute legal advice and are not intended to create an attorney-client relationship.

Please contact us to schedule a free consultation for legal advice specific to your situation.

Here are some articles that may interest you
Schedule a

Contact us for a Free Consultation

Schedule a free consultation

O'Flaherty Law is happy to meet with you by phone or at our office locations in:

Who We Are
We are your community law firm. Our Illinois & Iowa Attorneys are committed to providing exceptional client service in a cost-effective manner in the areas of Family Law, Probate, Estate Planning, Civil Litigation, Guardianship, Criminal Defense, Corporate & Contract Law, Bankruptcy and Real Estate.

Some of Our Accomplishments

Best Child Support Lawyers in Chicago
DuPage County Probate Attorney
Kevin P. O'Flaherty
Rated by Super Lawyers

loading ...
Naperville attorney
DuPage County Probate Attorney

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required